Is Health Care a Right or a Privilege?
Share
This week on This Ain’t It, we spent the episode talking about health care. The conversation started with the current moment: expiring ACA subsidies, rising premiums, and what those changes actually mean for people who already feel stretched thin. From there, we pulled back to look at how the United States ended up with a health care system so deeply tied to employment, and why losing a job so often means losing access to care.
How We Got an Employer-Based System
We walked through the history of American health insurance and how it became linked to work in the first place. Unlike other countries that built universal systems, the U.S. doubled down on employer-sponsored insurance, leaving huge gaps for anyone working part-time, self-employed, unemployed, or stuck in low-wage jobs without benefits.
That structure didn’t happen by accident. It grew out of political decisions, lobbying, and a cultural belief that health care should be earned, not guaranteed. The result is a system where access to doctors, medication, and treatment depends less on need and more on employment status.
The ACA, Subsidies, and What Happens When They Disappear
We also talked through the Affordable Care Act and how subsidies have helped keep coverage affordable for millions of people, and what happens when those supports expire. For many families, even small increases in monthly premiums are enough to push coverage out of reach.
When health insurance becomes unaffordable, people don’t stop getting sick. They just stop going to the doctor, delay care, ration medication, or take on debt.
When GoFundMe Becomes the Safety Net
We talk about how GoFundMe has quietly replaced communal responsibility, turning illness into a public appeal and forcing people to tell their most vulnerable stories just to access basic care.
Needing thousands of dollars for treatment isn’t rare — it’s expected. And the burden of asking, sharing, and hoping falls entirely on the person who’s already sick.
Faith, Scripture, and Care for the Sick
We also wrestled with the theological side of all this. Scripture is clear about caring for the sick, the poor, and the vulnerable, but modern American Christianity often treats health care as a political issue rather than a moral one.
We talked about the tension between individualism and communal responsibility, and how easily compassion gets overridden by arguments about cost, deservingness, or personal responsibility. When access to care is framed as a privilege, it becomes easier to ignore the human consequences.
So What Does This Say About Us?
What does it say about a society when health care depends on your job?
What does it say about the church when sickness becomes a private problem?
And what does it mean to claim faith while accepting a system that leaves people untreated, uninsured, and afraid?
Health care isn’t theoretical. It’s personal. And the choices we make — politically, economically, and spiritually — show who we believe is worth caring for.